December 19, 2025

Why Founders Blow It When They Hire Fast

Why Founders Blow It When They Hire Fast

‘We need someone in yesterday.’ Famous last words.

The other week I had a call with a founder – scaling a fintech, running hot, team slammed. He opens with: “Gozie, we needed this DevOps hire a month ago.”

I get it. Deadlines are looming. Stakeholders are growling. Pressure mounting.

So they do what most startups do in this moment of panic:

• Lower the bar
• Speed through interviews
• Fall in love with whoever seems ‘good enough’

Six weeks later? The hire's clashing with the culture, pushing the wrong priorities, and the founder's quietly fuming while updating their Notion board with ‘start rehiring’... again.

This is the curse of hiring under duress. You compromise on what matters most — and pay for it 10x over.

Stop hiring like you’re snogging at closing time

Let’s be real: scaling startups are a perfect petri dish for bad hires. The velocity! The ambiguity! The “can’t we just clone Priya on the data team?” energy.

But desperate hiring is like those last-minute dating decisions after four pints — based more on scarcity and lighting than actual compatibility.

And sure, sometimes it works out. But most of the time, it doesn’t.

I’ve watched startups:

• Burn £30K on a senior engineering hire who couldn’t scale past solo contributor mode
• Lose their most tenured team lead because the new CISO had the emotional IQ of a doorknob
• Blow investor confidence with a public tech fail courtesy of a hasty hire

Quick fixes tend to be short-lived. And very, very expensive.

Startups need conviction hiring, not speed dating

Here's a thought: the job of a scaling exec isn't to put bums on seats – it's to put the right minds in motion.

That means getting clear – painfully clear – on what matters more than technical skills:

• What will break if this hire is wrong? (That’s your risk lens.)
• What mission are they walking into? (Think beyond the JD.)
• What’s your team’s emotional weather right now? Sunny? Stormy? Draining?

Ask yourself: are you hiring someone for what they’ll build, fix or grow in 90 days — or for what looks good in the All Hands next week?

Here’s the Xist4 Anti-Rush Hiring Framework™

Catchy, no? Okay, maybe not. But useful:

• INTENT > INSTINCT: Define the success outcome before you define the role.
• TRUTH > TACT: Be brutally honest about your culture. Better to scare off the wrong person than wear a polite mask in interview.
• SIGNAL > NOISE: Build interviews that reveal behaviour under pressure — not just polished CVs or tech test scores.
• FIT > FOMO: Hiring just because a candidate is ‘great’ doesn’t mean they’re great for you. Know the difference.

Yes, this takes time. It demands more upfront. But so does recruiting again in 2.5 months when the rushed hire blows up like a dodgy lithium battery.

Don’t turn your team into a game of musical chairs

You only get so many chances to preserve momentum during scale. Every hire has second-order effects — they trigger reactions, shape culture, and either compound your team’s flow or clog it up.

When you rush a hire, here’s what also happens:

• The A-players exit quietly because the vibe changed
• The rest of the team slows down while onboarding someone who’ll likely churn
• The leadership team loses credibility from patchy judgment calls

This is why I push my clients hard. You don’t need someone fast. You need someone right — and right-sized for your stage, stakes and culture.

Final thoughts: Hire for signal, not panic

Look, I know the pressure. Funders want traction. Boards want metrics. Teams want relief.

But rushed hires are rarely brave. They're just expensive procrastination. You delay the pain while deepening the crack in your foundations.

If you're scaling and feeling the panic set in, here’s my challenge:

• Pause. No, seriously – stop and breathe.
• Clarify what this hire must achieve, not just what they need to know.
• Focus on alignment, not availability.

You’re building something special. Don’t sabotage it with a panicked yes. Be clear. Be picky. Be patient.

And if you want to steal some of my hiring battle scars and frameworks before you make your next big move — you know where to find me.

Back to news